New Age Old Town

Posted on April 30th, 2015 by Katie Faulkner

Posted under: Things We Like, Urban Design

Since March 1, I have read Casey Ross’ A New Age for an Old Town dozens of times.  The Boston Globe feature is interesting on a number of fronts; Mr. Ross describes our current “golden age of building” within the context of earlier waves of the 19th and 20th centuries that produced some of the city’s most beloved landmarks.  He takes us back to the 1964 construction site of the Prudential Tower, and even quotes John Hynes referring to Boston as the “Athens of America.”  The best thing about the article however, is the link to the sidebar graphic – a collection of articles chronicling 52 buildings that have either been provisionally approved or have actually started construction.  There is remarkable similarity among the images, and it is tempting to sort the buildings into piles: the plane-slippers, the wrapper-shifters, and the skirt-lifters.  In short, most are variations on the theme of maximizing a floor plate.

According to Casey Ross, and generally backed up by the BRA website, there is 34 million square feet of new building in the near-term Boston pipeline – this is Boston alone.  Imagine if we could add in Cambridge and Somerville. Within that number are other interesting stats.  At least 7 of the proposals are legitimate skyscrapers; 63% of the projects have a significant residential component, and most often the housing is paired with a hotel.  There are 29 development teams financing these projects, although there are recombinations and LLC’s that make it hard to count the players.  In a subsequent letter to the editor, architects Mark Pasnik and Michael Murphy note that Ross’ list of projects illustrates that development is an “insider’s game.”  They point out that two architecture firms are producing nearly a third of the 52 projects but stop short of revealing that Elkus Manfredi is involved with 25% of them.  In total there are about a dozen firms in the mix, with Miami’s Arquitectonica winning the “traveled the farthest” award.

If it hasn’t happened already, the City will soon designate a development team for the Winthrop Street Garage.  Ten years ago we would have called this Trans National Place.  At that time, developer Steve Belkin had engaged Renzo Piano to design a 1,000 foot tower.  The details of that project are the stuff of legend, and the upshot is that one cannot build a super-tower so close to Logan Airport.  Nonetheless, Belkin gets points for raising the architectural bar.  The original proposal had elegant proportions and tectonic heft that somehow gave unity to the eclectic volumes of Downtown. The reincarnation of the project promises to be both shorter and less inspired, but it will nonetheless take its place on Boston’s skyline as a marker of this our 21st century “golden age of building.”

Trans National Place designed by Renzo Piano

Trans National Place designed by Renzo Piano

 

Harvard professor Edward Glaeser wrote that “(r)eally tall buildings provide something of an index of irrational exuberance,” and he points to the iconic Empire State and Chrysler Buildings as examples.  To his point, towers generally go up in economic boom times, and emerging economies continue to show their might by sponsoring increasingly stunning and tall buildings.  In contrast, Boston towers do not tend to be particularly tall, and the City seems not to see them as icons of our urban greatness, which is a shame because once it is up, a tower becomes an indelible part of our identity.  Much as we might like to erase One International Place, it’s not going anywhere.

Construction of the Empire State Building

Construction of the Empire State Building

 

As I was penning this blog, Rachel Slade published her scathing “Why is Boston so Ugly?” piece in Boston Magazine.  This is the article many of us have wanted to write but could not articulate.  She called out the visual affront of 111 Huntington, and the lost opportunities of the Seaport District.  The conventional wisdom that it is hard to get anything built in Boston is called a bluff.  It is actually ridiculously easy to build just about anything if you know the right people.   Ms. Slade takes on the BRA and exposed the long tenure of the BCDC members.  Most endearing was that she listed NADAAA among the “most vigorous design firms,” although I did not appreciate her assessment that firms like ours lack the capacity for big buildings.  Capacity is not the issue.  Jonathan Levi Architects won the Harleston Parker medal with an 84,000 square foot public school and the firm has designed millions of square feet of institutional, residential, and educational buildings.  Anmahian Winton Architects have a high-rise under construction in Ankara.  David Hacin has mid-rise residential buildings all over town, and is in fact one of the prospective design teams for Winthrop Square.  NADAAA just completed the 250,000 square foot Melbourne School of Design, the result of an open international competition, and has larger projects in design and construction. What binds the work of these firms together is not their relatively small size. The common thread is architectural intent, which unfortunately has become separated from the merely functional as if to say that the added value of design is luxurious excess.  Undaunted, Rachel Slade looks for bigger fish out of town and references significant buildings in New York and Chicago, cities with a legacy of great architectural ambition and civic pride.  In her assessment, Boston comes up short and she is right. With notable exceptions, Boston developers are generally indifferent to design. At a ULI meeting last year, a prominent Boston developer admitted that ultimately he does not care what his buildings look like.  There are complex negotiations, oversight agencies, fickle markets, and prescribed profit margins to be dealt with — this is perhaps why few locals hang out in the Seaport District.  Ultimately one does need to care.

002-dso-2

Ankara Office Building designed by Cambirdge-based Anmahian Winton Architects

Melbourne School of Design by Boston-based NADAAA

Melbourne School of Design by Boston-based NADAAA

 

The combination of the current gilded age with a new administration has provided an opportunity to correct the trajectory of the current building boom, and there are guiding principles to light the way.  First, Boston’s built environment should reflect the region’s rich culture, and the ambition of what we’d like to be.  Architecture carries the weight of history as well as the demonstration of invention, technology and civilization.  Related to this is the obligation to be respectful of the historical layers of our urbanism without being imitative or mocking.  Second, it is incumbent upon all constructors – designers, policy makers, and builders – to respect a kind of Hippocratic oath.  Do no harm, and when possible advance social well-being.  Architecture has the power to mediate certain landscape and urban challenges in ways no other medium can.  Consider the legacy of Mecanoo/Sasaki’s Bolling Municipal Building.  Surely it deserves some credit for the fact that for the second quarter in a row (according to Boston Business Journal), Roxbury’s Dudley Square neighborhood ranked as the Commonwealth’s hottest real estate market. Finally, one should not separate the functional from the courageous; a well-designed building is not a luxury, it is a basic right like clean water, functional infrastructure and access to the Internet.  By separating the practical from the beautiful, we are all but guaranteeing bad design, undermining our potential as a progressive city. When our own mayor joins the chorus by calling Boston’s latest bumper crop of buildings “merely functional”, it is time to expect more.

Mayor Marty Walsh  Photo from Bostoninno

Mayor Marty Walsh, photo from Bostoninno

Comments Off on New Age Old Town

MSD featured in INDESIGN Magazine

Posted on April 30th, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: _Melbourne School of Design, Press

Tom Kvan, Dean of Architecture, Building and Planning at the MSD and Andrew Hutson, Deputy Dean wrote for INDESIGN magazine on how the new Melbourne School of Design meets the needs of “a new generation of educators and students”.

INDESIGN magazine MSD 2015 - blog

Comments Off on MSD featured in INDESIGN Magazine

MSD FEATURED ON ARCHDAILY

Posted on April 23rd, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: _Melbourne School of Design, Press

The Melbourne School of Design is featured today on ArchDaily 

MSD on ArchDaily

Photo: Peter Bennetts

Comments Off on MSD FEATURED ON ARCHDAILY

A Hat Trick for SARANY

Posted on April 23rd, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: _Melbourne School of Design, Awards

NADAAA has won three SARANY awards this year:

Gold, silver and bronze! New Hampshire, Toronto and Melbourne!

SARANY 2015 3

Comments Off on A Hat Trick for SARANY

SYMPOSIUM: INTERSECTIONS IN PEDAGOGY

Posted on April 22nd, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: Academic, Events, Lectures

Nader will join Stan Allen, Amale Andraos, Kent Kleinman, Irene Sunwoo, Martha Thorne, and Matthias Sauerbruch for Brown University and RISD’s joint symposium: Intersections in Pedagogy this Saturday, April 25 from 9:00am-5:00pm at the List Art Center Auditorium at Brown University. Bernard Tschumi will give a keynote address the evening before at the RISD Auditorium. For more information click here.

 

AUH_Poster_FINALtoPRINT_3_31

Comments Off on SYMPOSIUM: INTERSECTIONS IN PEDAGOGY

WEARING THE MSD

Posted on April 22nd, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: _Melbourne School of Design, Things We Like

The hanging studio has been re-imagined as wearable art by Shereen Amin and Amanda Luu, students of Monash University’s Art, Design and Architecture program (MADA). ‘After painstakingly developing a gradient panelization system, thick and massive on one end while thin and suspended on the other, the Beaux Arts Ball rectified this trope by a classical tri-partite rendition with a base, shaft, and top section strategically aligned with figural protrusions.’ – Nader Tehrani

WEARING-MSD-blog

Photograph: Matthew Stanton

Comments Off on WEARING THE MSD

MSD in MARK

Posted on April 21st, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: _Melbourne School of Design, Press

John Wardle, Stefan Mee and Nader discuss the Melbourne School of Design in issue 55 of MARK Magazine.

“I don’t think the building proclaims its pedagogical lessons in an overt form. The real lessons are to be learned in its intrinsic detail. It’s more about our hopes of inviting enough curiosity to have users examine the detail.” – John Wardle

IMG_7601

IMG_7611-blog

Comments Off on MSD in MARK

Model Home Gallery in Trama

Posted on April 17th, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: Press

The Raemian Model Home Gallery is featured in the current issue of TRAMA.

Portada-Trama-129-blog

Casa-Modelo-blog

Comments Off on Model Home Gallery in Trama

XIX Bienal Arquitectura + Educación / Chile 2015

Posted on April 16th, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: Lectures

Nader will lecture this Sunday at the XIX Bienal Arquitectura + Educación at 4:00pm in the Teatro del Edificio MP in Valparaíso, Chile. The theme of the Bienal is “El País Que Queremos” – “The Country We Want”. Live Streaming Here

valparaiso-blog-2015

Comments Off on XIX Bienal Arquitectura + Educación / Chile 2015

Seaholm Wall Progress

Posted on April 16th, 2015 by Nicole Sakr

Posted under: construction, Urban Design

Under construction in the heart of downtown Austin, Texas, a one-thousand four-hundred foot screen wall is taking shape. Situated along Shoal Creek and several adjacent developments including the New Central Library, the project helps to secure an active power station and create urban spaces along its perimeter. The wall will employ over eight hundred 8 x 8 x 12 foot tall integrally colored concrete posts with varying patterns and rotations.

southeast corner-2-blog

 

Process color studies

study-blog

color-studies-8

Comments Off on Seaholm Wall Progress